Reelin’ in the years – Steely Dan


Irresistible is a word I overuse.

Or maybe I just don’t have much resistance.

I’ve already talked about the fact that for me the ultimate test of pop is whether it makes you want to engage with it. Whether it brings you in, takes you by the hand. Whether it makes you want to sing, dance, move, cry, or melt into infinity.

This is a song that will reel you in, again and again.

I can’t remember the last time I listened to it just one time, when I had the power to skip back.

Reelin’ in the years.

Everything. Every single thing.

The whole song is structured to pull you in, to lift you up and keep you moving.

It starts with the first hook. This warm fuzz of guitar just dancing up and down and around the point, while everything else stays steady.

This pattern stays. Most things stay super simple, to let one element at a time take the weight of the song. This is simple stuff, but here it’s used mostly to give a favour to everything else. Quite often things will repeat with an added flourish, once anything is established as the norm, it can be complicated. Powered up.

My normal trick when writing these is to put the track on repeat and just keep on writing, picking out details. Right now, it feels like I’m in an infinite loop. It never relents, even as it fades, even in that first instant. The drums pluck out this simple insistence. The bass oscillates.

And the singer talks, and the singer sings.

And. That. Damn. Guitar.

Are you reelin’ in the years?

Are you stowing away the time?

Are you gathering up the tears?

Have you had enough of mine?

The words feel sad and nostalgic, laced with a mean spirited bitterness. It’s about entitlement, and basically a bit of a shitbag song.

So fuck that shit. The words don’t matter. It’s about that feeling.

First the near spoken verses are damn fun to speak along with. Lovely little rhymes and flourishes, and an immaculate sense of rhythm. Then the chorus is simple enough that anyone can grasp it. It’s a hard sing, quite an odd pitch. But it’s a bloody joy.

But really, the moment it gets me, and the moment I feel like it could get anyone, is when that guitar solo kicks in.

Apparently most of the rest of the track was already recorded, and they just got Elliot Randal to come and layer a guitar over the whole song. You can hear how he waits for times he can respond. It adds to that layering I mentioned above. It’s just bursts to begin with. Flourishes and responses.

But then it kicks in for real.

It’s painfully irresistible. The temptation to rip out an air guitar and pull yourself along with those noodles is incredible. Even the song can’t stop itself, slamming piano and everything else into the second repeat. Again, add a layer once something is clearly established. Here it works beautifully, taking my hands out of air guitar and in to a ridiculous mix of air piano, air drums, jazz hands, and sassy, sassy mime. If my shoulders weren’t already bouncing, they are now. It pours its joy through your body. Surprisingly patiently.

It’s not rocket science, but it is a guitar part simple but effective and weighty enough to grab you. It sounds fun. It sounds like moving your body in that rhythm is going to be entertaining, but it’s too fast for my hips, so it just begs me to take up guitar.

I’m still livid that I’ve never got to play it on Guitar Hero. I’m awful, but that’s the closest I’m going to get, and I want to have the feeling of that solo coursing through my fingers.

It’s not clever. But it is perfect.

It comes in for a second run at the end, too. And it still just takes you back in. And I think that’s the trick here.

This is pop that doesn’t want to stress or strain you. It just wants you to be left wanting more. It wants you to play with it. It wants you to bounce with it. Sing with it. Wiggling your hands like a tit with it.

And frankly, I’m not one to refuse the irresistible.


Take Time – The Books


I’m not going to say that this is the weirdest thing I’m ever going to try and claim is pop for the sake of this blog. But it’ll be in the running.

A cut and paste mass of archive recordings, sliced up guitar, percussive plonks and who knows what else.

But by god, it lifts my heart, it wraps me up, and I think it has something deep and important to tell us about music and life and everything.

Take time.

For the first time in the history of the world a young girl climbed into a tree one day.

She climbed down from the tree next day.

God bless her.

Music is a fundamentally temporal experience. It is the arrangement of noises over time. Normally fitting particularly familiar patterns.

This song is a clear instruction. Take time. Take time.

It asks you to do it, and it makes you do it.

Music is a way to spend time, but also a way to make you notice it passing. Music has a habit of pulling you into a moment. Deepening the moment. Whether sat in bed writing, wandering through a forest with headphones, pressed up against a train window or dancing the night away, music can be with you, pulling you deeper.

It never tells us what to take the time to do. I recommend you take some time time to take time with take time. It’s worth pouring yourself into its odd little headspace, and just listening to the wonderful array of voices on offer.

The glorious, joyful laughter of it.

Something is happening that is not happening.

It’s okay to take time for yourself. To not happen, and revel in that. Music begs you to do this. To experience the now as deeply as it can allow. To be in your body and feel what it feels when presented with such a particular, alien and specific stimulus.

Music is probably the most unnatural thing that feels the most wholesome.

I take that back, because I don’t believe in the words nature or unnatural. But it’s important to remember that music doesn’t really exist outside of time, mathematics, and familiarity. The patterns make sense only because of that mathematical specificity (the intervals between particular pitches, and particular moments) and the amount of time you’ve spent exposed to those particular patterns.

Music makes you take time, because it is made out of time. It is simply sound objects manipulated in time.

The abrupt artifice and bluntness and spasmodic pulsing of this song should help make that clearer. It starts insistent and unpleasant. Wraps you in a recording of Medea. Then laughter, laughter and whooping.

Take time.

It’s all people.

By the time you hear the first simply played guitar, you’ve already heard so many voices. Each speaking directly to you, and tugging at you.

If music is alien, on closer inspection, then what happens when you make music out of humans?

For me, it’s a burst heart. A thoughtful mind. An affirmation.

You won’t find the meaning of life in this song, or any song. At least partly because there isn’t one. Maybe.

What you will find, though, is a way to remind yourself what life is.

Just the organisation of actions through time.

A chance to move and feel and listen and be.

Take time to do that. Take time to listen.

Pay attention.

Fill your heart with time.

Let time pour out from you, through you.

And revel in the fucker. Because you won’t have it forever.

Take time.

Solsbury Hill – Peter Gabriel


As I write this, I can still feel the dried tears on my cheeks.

I cried sheets of tears during the closing episodes of Halt and catch fire, a shockingly heart-filled alternate history of the computing revolutions of the 80s and 90s.

It was mostly because I knew I was spending the last hours with a group of people I’d become remarkably close to, after forty hours of television, and about fifteen years of their fictional lives.

But it was also because the perfect moment was accompanied by the perfect song.

Solsbury Hill.

TV has a way of working songs deep into your consciousness, and I think this one has got me. A good sound director recognises a song that creates a feeling, and I feel like this song has driven a lot of those feelings.

There’s a rehabilitative process in soundtracking. Every song becomes a pop cliché once it’s been around long enough, and it’s hard to shake off some of the naffness of history. But some combination of nostalgia and revisionism slowly open your heart, and let’s things in.

Solsbury hill is a song I would’ve cast aside as pap in my youth. Corny and cheesy, fusty and bland.

But now it lives in my heart, warms me, fills me, opens me up.

My heart going boom, boom, boom

It’s about climbing up a hill, and touching the sky. Letting the abundance of nature into your heart.

It feels like marching up a hill. It has that tugging effort, and the constant sense of opening out. It relentlessly marches, expanding and lifting. A (mostly) 7/4 time signature pulls it onwards, ever onwards. Like a lot of rhythms just shy of a simpler 4, (cf some future piece about Hey Ya), it gains a relentlessness from the sense of nearly catching up with itself. Perpetually.

It even satisfies that, with tiny slivers of 4/4 at the ends of each chorus.

It’d be a cheap trick, if it wasn’t so breathlessly perfect. If each of those choruses didn’t feel exactly like reaching the top of a hill and sucking in a stunning view.

I’m never where I want to be

There’s a feeling I absolutely adore in music. A physical feeling, generated where harmonies thicken and open out. It feels like my chest is pulling outwards. Like my world and my heart and my mind are getting bigger.

I think it’s a trick. I think it’s just playing the same theme on slightly more instruments, while simplifying the chord just a little. Giving a bit more space to the sound, but also a bit more heft. Each element of noise feels more particular, more personal. And I am lifted.

Peter Gabriel, from the little I know, is excellent at this. He has a concrete grip on the space of a song, the weight of it. And he uses it here to create a constant, permanent outward swell.

You aren’t just climbing a hill, you are expanding your view. Expanding your whole world. The song does it too. Even right to the yelps of boggarts and elves in final crescendo.

The song takes you by the hand with that opening guitar hook. Pulls you along with strings and words. And fulfils every promise it makes.

Just had to trust imagination

Not many people could make your heart go boom boom boom with the words ‘my heart’s going boom boom boom’. But here it’s perfect.

It’s archetypal explodeypops.

My heart’s going boom boom boom.

Once in a lifetime – Talking Heads


It’s not exactly out on a limb to suggest that this one’s a banger, but I want to talk about how it actually makes me feel.

Surrounded by water. Drowning, swimming. Lost and confused, but held.

Once in a lifetime.

Partly it’s familiarity. It’s hard to argue with a song you’ve heard a million times before, one whose shimmering, stuttering video feels like a part of history.

But there’s more than that. There’s this rigid, jerky instrumental, under a glistening sea of synthesised radiation. And then there’s David.

It’s not enough to be a song about angst, about fear and not knowing. The words matter, but they aren’t the everything. You can hear it in the quiver of the voice, the strange desperation.

My god, what have I done

Even outside the lytics, the chorus argues with itself, pulling in two directions. Upward and downward. But the song pushes relentlessly forward. Just like the progress that David feels terrified of.

When I first hear that intro, my heart shudders. There’s this recognition, and this contentment. But there’s a thread under the contentment, a thread of fear and incomprehension. Am I really ready to have the rug pulled from under me? Am I ready to question where I am?

And you may ask yourself, How do I work this?

And that’s incredible. Because that’s the theme of the lyrics. That’s what the song is about, or at least part of it. Contentment, undermined but held on to. A fear of letting go of the thing that traps you. A fear of life.

David breaks down, pulled apart by large automobiles, worn down by water above, and below. But throughout he is preaching, beckoning and holding on.

The final guitar rips through the top of the song. Just thick, weighted noise. The whole song is thick with shifts in texture over a static but lustrous rhythm.

Just try and focus down on the core drum beat. It’s heart thumping. Just this simple, open heartbeat. It’s impossible to keep attention at just that level. Everything else wraps around it, and plays with it.

The bass is strapped right into it, that stark throb of bass. It’s a voice at the bottom of everything. Some ominous refrain, flowing underneath. Keyboards jut into it, with gripping little details and immense bursts of counterpoint.

And that shimmering, glistening layer of water.

There’s so many details here, but all of it is just lost, drowned and only occasionally bubbling to prominence.

At heart, this is a song, a song that is mostly spoken. A song that is mostly shouted.

And the words, tear at me. And the voice, tears at me. The one brief torrent of distortion and echo is terrifying. The call and response is haunting and uplifting. The whole piece is water. The thing you swim in, but can’t see.

I still can’t work out if they’re tears of joy or pain.

It may well be both.

It’s incredible to see an honest to goodness pop hit that holds those multitudes within. Something about pain that is irresistibly uplifting. Something that is so cheerfully terrifying.

Let the days go by. Water flows underground. Once in a lifetime.

I don’t know what I’m supposed to do. A once in the lifetime chance to let the days go by.

What should I ask myself?

There is water at the bottom of the ocean.

And I’m swimming there.

Q.U.E.E.N – Janelle Monáe


It’s not even the most perfect pop song Janelle Monáe has made, but it’s still one of the fiercest out there.


In Janelle’s Metropolis suite (possibly the best set of concept albums ever made), queerness, blackness and robotness are wrapped around each other and permeate every work in a fiery web of resistance and empathy. Those letters stand for Queer community, Untouchables, Emigrants, Excommunicated and  ‘for those labelled as Negroid‘. An intentional anthem for the marginalised, we have this insatiable bassline wrapped around a conversation about queerness and judgement that sets me on fire every time.

Simultaneously inclusive and confrontational, Janelle rides this particular tightrope presenting questions about societal unacceptability that throw them into relief and act as calls to unity, a cry of solidarity. Yes, it’s okay to dance late at night, twerk in the mirror and throw bones on the ground. The questions are reconstructed as defiance, rejecting assumed answers and declaring solid independence.

Am I a freak for dancing around?
Am I a freak for getting down?
I’m cutting up, don’t cut me down
Yeah I wanna be, wanna be QUEEN

She does that subtle thing of never quite making it clear what she’s talking about, whilst building bonds with those in the know. The sly references to queerness, blackness and other marginalised identities could be missed by someone just seeing a song about taking to the dancefloor with a bit of extra sass, but here the dance is political, rejecting religious resistance.

The whole thing almost sounds borderline footloose, until the song tilts. Erykah Badu takes us to one side, promises a melody that can show us another way, and then Janelle brings down the fire.

Janelle’s rap at the end of this track is one of those utterly excoriating calls to arms that deserve to change the world.

Are we a lost generation of our people?
Add us to equations but they’ll never make us equal
She who writes the movie owns the script and the sequel
So why ain’t the stealing of my rights made illegal?

An explicit case is made, dancing might bring us together, but we need to take that unity to the streets, with solidarity and purpose, we need to mark our difference, celebrate it, and set the world on fire.

When Janelle says she doesn’t think they understand what she’s trying to say, and then burns the world with her words (in a voice so distinctly different I always thought it was Badu), it’s just incredible.

And it’s matched in the music. Everything has toned down to a quietness, and then as Janelle’s fire catches, the music opens up into this world spanning mass of strings. The textural shift from this voice and violin is legitimately one of the most perfect storms in all of music. This section of this song literally takes my breath away. I feel more alive when I listen to it, even though occasionally it fills me with all the urgent emotion of a panic attack. It pulls down on my insides and fills me with hope and, yes, fire.

Great pop can burn with a light bright and hot, and this does. It’s bright enough to bring us together, and hot enough to melt shackles. A song about fighting for freedom, resisting the world, and making it change.

Will you be electric sheep? Electric ladies, will you sleep?
Or will you preach?

Janelle’s dark future dystopia is no worse than the world today. That’s what she’s singing about. It’s real, it’s here, and we need to fight the fuck out of it.

Music and sci-fi can both be escapist, but they can also wake us up.

And this song is the funkiest, most furious alarm call you will find.

Listen close.

I couldn’t say it to your face – Arthur Russell


It’s odd that my first Arthur Russell pick should be a dose of countrified sad pop that might be too bleak to be pop.

But, well, it’s perfect and small and sharp and heartfelt. So it’s here.

I couldn’t say it to your face.

It’s actually pretty banal at this point to say that silences can make these glorious and empty holes in a track that punctuate perfectly. But it’s also true. And this song features some of the most heartbreaking pauses you’ll ever hear. Encased in blasts of horn, they feel like regret made solid. You can hear Arthur’s heart break in those silences. You can hear every ounce of forgiveness that isn’t forthcoming.

Country music is probably the genre I’m least engaged with. But I know it’s famous for it’s sadness, regret and relentless moving on. This song captures all of that, and wraps it in horn, drum, piano and voice.

The brass is fantastic, quiet, high and intensely forlorn. It skirts around the edges, and just scores those emotions with these occasional bursts of brashness. The depth of sadness as it kicks in after each pause is heart fracturing, even just that horn would do it.

Then the steady and ever so slightly out of tune organ that underpins everything.

The whole song sounds half finished and worn out. Arthur’s voice and the drums are the most insistent and solid thing here (ironic for a song about not being able to talk), everything else pulls back, holds us down, underlines the sadness.

But it’s certain. Confident. It know it’s the right thing, despite all the doubt in those silences. It’s defiant.

It’s my world
It’s my song
Didn’t ask you to sing along;
In my arms, you girl, you won’t be here to say I’m wrong

Maybe it isn’t even sad. Maybe it’s about freedom. Maybe it’s not doubt in those silences. Maybe it’s certainty. Solidity. Movement.

Whatever it is, it’s so sharp and pointed and powerful that I can’t put it down. It’s a perfect statement in a short space of time. It’s got moments that pull you in. It pounds and slams you forward. It’s powerful pop. It’s the right sort of heartbreak.

Arthur’s better known for his experimental cello and weird-as-hell disco. It’s kind of strange that this record of country and folk songs exists, but they show a passion for pop even deeper and simpler than his passion for odd noises and squawking, lolloping disco.

Here Arthur masters an emotion in just a few minutes, with just a few tools. It’s a perfect arrangement, simple and solid and oh so gripping.

And every pause drowns me. Every return lifts me up.

Sad pop isn’t about feeling sad, it’s about feeling intensely. It’s about feeling as much as you can.

This song begs you to feel. It beckons you into a quilt of sadness and hope. It wraps you in horn and piano and Arthur’s oh so hearted voice.

I wish I could have said it to his face, but he’ll always have my heart.

The Rhythm Changes – Kamasi Washington


It’s definitely way too early to start my pitch for jazz standards as archetypal pop and The Rhythm Changes as a new jazz standard candidate, but the opening keys of this track have already got their hooks in me, and I’ve no power to resist.

It’s not that big a leap to call the jazz standards the pop of their era, and you’d need a brighter and more informed mind than me to actually dig into the meaning of the word pop at a time when people still gathered round the piano with scores bought for pennies or went to stage shows purely because they knew a new banger would be promised. I’ll simplify it though: as short, hooky songs which begged listeners and performers to get involved and put their own stamp on them, those jazz classics absolutely fit any criteria I’m willing to throw at a song to call it pop.

And frankly, if you don’t see some Gershwin and Porter on these pages before I finish, it means I’ve given up shockingly early.

But this isn’t yet a standard, it’s a seven minute jam, heaped with solos, from a three hour long maximalist jazz record. It doesn’t matter that Kamasi is as trad as fuck, trying to reinvigorate the big band scene with a huge swell of great music and great musicians. The fact is that jazz isn’t pop these days.

Except maybe to nerds like me, digging away to find gems like this.

That opening fuzz of organ and keys is exhilarating beyond belief, slowly coming from nowhere and ripping you in it. The drums lollop in and the piano fills out the theme and before you know it you’ve got a swing in your step.

Patrice Quinn owns the moment wholly. Her voice punctuates and proposes. It doesn’t need the choir and brass that eventually start padding her out, but my god does it feel deservedly decadent and lustrous when it does.

The rises endlessly, always building and lifting and pulling you up. Always more open, always stronger, always more fascinating. The solos are often simple and straightforward, and they don’t outstay their welcome, just provide one or other viewpoint on the way up this glorious hill of a song. Somehow begging you to pound your feet ever upwards, filled with promise and change.

The rhythm never changes, ironically, it’s such a steady, solid roll. But it’s perfect, because everything else changes around it. It’s this perfectly smooth grounding layer to keep everything else recognisably whole, no matter how off course the performers want to take it.

It’s probably why I think of it as a standard actually. The core of the track is so simple and ubiquitous that it provides that bed of expectation you kind of need for good jazz to really get its hooks in.

For me the benefit of the standard is that you know what it’s supposed to do, so when a particular performer plays fast and loose with it, you know where it’s coming from, even if you don’t know where it’s being taken. The deconstruction feels familiar, knowable. It’s why jazz covers are so common, because you know what’s being done to a song you’ve heard a million times before, you get to hear it afresh, with new ears. Just like the first time.

Here the same effect is created by just creating that simple, irresistible progression, defining it with a perfect vocal, then letting a sequence of instrumentalists pull it apart, ever so gently. Once it’s handed back to Patrice, you should already be firmly ensconced in the world of the song, and that finale will just leave you begging for more.

It’s one of the subtler, simpler and least resistible tracks on Kamasi’s Epic, but it’s also one of the best examples of a pop delicacy I’ve heard from jazz in many years.

If you have a chance, see it live, I guarantee you it will thicken, swell and burst your heart before you’re even halfway through. What happens after that I can’t make promises about. I felt like I was on fire, in love and lifted to heaven all at once.

Just like all the best pop. For sure.

Let the rhythm change you.

Pharoahs – SBTRKT


Sometimes pop is a landscape you move through.

Sometimes pop is a bottle you fill up, like a liquid, with your self.

Pharoahs, by SBTRKT is both of these things, and so much more.

It’s a simple framework, on the surface. Every element is tiny, clear and sharp (until the filters take over and blur it all into a mass of noise, but even that is done with a precision that very, very carefully overwhelms). Everything has space to breathe and stand alone. It deconstructs itself with it’s simplicity.

I need me a golden crown

Roses Gabor smoothly slides a layer of silken vocal over the top, providing punctuation and process to the song, but at its heart, this is a (sweetly) mechanical machine for making you move.

The drum beat is almost the simplest possible assembly of beats. Kick Snare Kick Snare Kick Snare Kick Snare. The most immaculate maraca in the business emphasising every in between.

It’s almost child’s play. You couldn’t come up with something simpler if you tried, but it is made so pointed and sharp by the simple clipping of every sound. Each element is separated from each other by the barest thread, enough of a gap to squeeze yourself into. It practically begs you to fill that space, to find a body part to wedge into every motion. It’s a ‘learn to shake ass’ kind of rhythm, making everything as simple as possible.

You can see how integral that cleanness is to everything by hearing what happens to the rest of the music every time the drum beat isn’t there. The drum keeps things in check, restrains it and purifies it. When those filters start blurring the lines between voice, melody and bass, the drums drop out, and everything gets lost in a kind of ecstatic tumult.

Again, it perfectly lets you ooze out of shape, it’s an invitation to let your dance get a little bit looser, more fluid, higher, more elastic.

And the drums kick back, and everything tightens, and so do you – having been relaxed into something more physical, more free.

This song wants to teach you how to love dancing. With every ounce of its self, it wants you moving with it.

The synth elements, a sassy strutting bass with accompanying organ harmonics provide a wash of nightclub neon. They glow, sometimes through smoke, to make room for Roses. Together they seduce. For all its danceability, the scene is much closer to a night drive through bright lights than the club itself.

But it’s definitely dancing that you’re being driven to.

All I see is you,


Open arms,

Roses makes you the centre of the universe, even as she calls for her crown. But it’s because her kingdom is the gift she’s giving you, and in this case, the gift is movement, freedom and an irresistible desire to purse your lips and shake your hips.

Sass is one of my favourite things in music, a kind of sharpened femme aggression that can be expressed simply through a perfect harmonising of hips, bass and kick drums. It’s hard to capture, but a lot of my favourite pop bottles it, and then pours it back over me. It’s music that makes me feel like I’m moving more like myself than I could be without the music.

It’s music that fills me up, shakes me and then pours me back into it’s rhythm.

Liquid, perfect, and inescapably danceable.


How to explodeypops


This is a sequel, of sorts.

Queen: an exploded diagram (aka Exploded Queen) was a big messy and glorious celebration of everything Queen. Literally everything. Every track from every Queen studio album. Even the ones I didn’t like (or at least, didn’t think I liked).

But this isn’t about Queen, because I already did that.

This is about pop.

Now, I’m going to hit a block almost immediately, in that I think I define pop differently to most people, so really, just about anything could end up in here. For me, pop is music that invites you in and asks you to take part in it. Music that wants you to sing, dance, clap or bounce along.

I guess you could argue that’s most music, and you might be right. So yeah, I could take this anywhere.

So maybe it’s not about pop, maybe it’s just about celebrating the way I engage with music, and the way I hope other people do.

It’s a simple set up, really, I’m going to pick a song, and rant about it. I might look at its dynamics, its history, its politics, its lyrics, places I’ve heard it, things I’ve felt about it. It could be anything. All you’re guaranteed is a set of thoughts about a thing I like.

It’s going to be amazing though. Because I’m going to pick songs I love, and I’m hopefully going to make you love them too.

Music to me is a really physical experience. Songs don’t often make me cry, but they always do something to my body. I’ve had ‘good panic attacks’ listening to a song, where it felt like my heart was going to actually jump out of my throat, and my body might melt into the ground. A song as triggered a burst of love for an old friend that started in my nose and radiated through my body like the sun jumping out from a cloud. Songs have made me dance, fall over, shiver and stare at ceilings.

The right music, at the right time, is the most blissful and inexplicable experience.

And to be clear, I’m not ever going to try and explain why something is so blissful. Life isn’t actually about whys.

I’m just going to give you impressions, thoughts, and enthusiasm.

At the very least, it might remind you to find some music and turn it up loud.

And maybe it’ll be the song that’ll make your heart explode.